RRSP Meltdown Calculator (whether it beats leaving it alone)
Does the meltdown actually win? Melt the RRSP against deductible loan interest — or leave it compounding. Both sides compared.
Updated · Reviewed by Ramin Hallaji, principal broker & founder ·Calculator
✓ Verified math — proven against independent references and last checked October 15, 2026; the full proof is under "How this is figured," below the results.
On these numbers · after 15 years
Meltdown ahead by $4,999
The borrowed portfolio clears $147,417 after repaying the loan — more than the $142,419 the melted dollars would have kept inside the RRSP after 45% tax. The higher that later rate, the cheaper the melted dollars were.
RUN THE MELTDOWN$576,704
RRSP remainder after tax $429,287 + borrowed portfolio $147,417 after the loan is repaid.
LEAVE THE RRSP INTACT$571,705
No loan, no withdrawals — untouched compounding, taxed at the later rate on the way out.
Borrowed portfolio, after repaying the loan+$147,417
What the melted dollars would have kept, after tax−$142,419
Net effect of running the strategy+$4,999
Cash-flow reality: on a $12,000 annual withdrawal the institution withholds 20% ($2,400) at source — outside Québec: 10% to $5,000, 20% to $15,000, 30% above. A prepayment reconciled at tax filing, not an extra cost, but the year-one wallet feels it.
How this is figured — assumptions & the printed proof
How this is figured: each year the RRSP compounds at 5.0%, then $12,000 (the loan interest) is withdrawn and pays the lender; the withdrawal's tax and the interest deduction cancel. The $200,000 borrowed compounds at the same return net of 25% annual drag and repays the loan at the end. Whatever remains in the RRSP is taxed at 45%. The melt-year bracket never appears — it cancels out of both sides. Verification: with no loan the two paths are identical to the cent ($571,705 both sides at these defaults); with a 0% return the strategy loses exactly the after-tax value of every melted dollar (−$99,000 over 15 years) — the model refuses the free-lunch story. The year-by-year loop matches the closed-form drained-RRSP formula to the cent ($780,521 pre-tax at defaults), and the decomposition reconciles exactly: portfolio +$147,417 minus melted dollars −$142,419 = the +$4,999 gap between the bars.
What this calculator refuses to pretend
The pitch says RRSP withdrawals come out "tax-free." The arithmetic says something sharper: the melted dollars are consumed paying loan interest — what the strategy really does is fund that interest with pre-tax money and add investment leverage. Whether that beats leaving the RRSP alone depends on the return, the borrowing cost, and the tax rate those dollars would eventually face. The unleveraged cousin lives in the drawdown calculator; the full strategy is set out in the RRSP meltdown explainer.
The meltdown is a pairing — an advisor who owns the sequencing and a broker who structures deductible-interest borrowing correctly. The desk is the second half.
Illustration only — deliberately simplified, and not tax or investment advice. The model assumes the withdrawal exactly equals the loan interest and the deduction fully offsets the withdrawal's tax — which requires the direct-use rule to be satisfied and enough income to absorb the deduction, both the accountant's boxes to tick. Withholding at source is a prepayment squared up at filing. Returns are applied evenly; real portfolios don't do that, and leverage cuts both ways. Private Wealth Financing arranges the financing; an advisor and accountant own the plan.